The Verdict That Shook English Football
The Premier League confirmed on Tuesday that City were found guilty of almost all of the 115 financial charges they faced. That means 114 guilty findings, covering breaches between 2009 and 2018. The news had already leaked days earlier through The Athletic’s David Ornstein, so the confirmation landed like a thunderclap.
City are not going quietly. The club said it was disappointed and surprised, insisted it was innocent, and promised to be relentless in pursuing an appeal.
What Did Manchester City Actually Do?
According to the ruling, the breaches were not small. The league said City used sham commercial contracts to artificially inflate revenues and cut costs by more than 900 million pounds, with secret funding from their Abu Dhabi owners. The findings span nine seasons, from 2009-10 to 2017-18. Al JazeeraAl Jazeera
Why Rivals Say Relegation Is Not Enough
Here is where it gets spicy. Rival clubs are demanding huge punishments, with senior figures warning that even a points deduction would not go far enough. One source close to a leading club put it bluntly: the general view is that a points deduction, no matter how big, is not enough. gbnewsgbnews
The demands are growing. Reports say relegation, a forced sale and lifetime bans are all being urged, and some sources expect a deduction spanning more than one season. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has warned that expulsion could be the ultimate sanction. Remember, these are demands, not decisions.
Then there is the money. City could also face compensation claims from opponents who believe they lost out during the affected seasons.
How Big Could the Punishment Be?
Look at the precedent. Everton and Nottingham Forest were docked points in 2023-24 for single breaches of financial rules. City’s case is on a different planet. Football finance expert Kieran Maguire suggested a penalty of 40 to 60 points, and one outlet calculated that even 40 points would have left City 18th last season. Under Rule W64, the commission can fine a club, deduct points or expel it.
What Happens Next for Man City?
No sanction has been announced yet. The same independent commission that found City guilty must now agree on the penalty. Timing is the next fight. If a sanction applies before the appeal is heard, City could be relegated and later cleared. If not, they could keep their points this season, which could cost rivals a place in Europe or even their top-flight status. City currently lead the Premier League. Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak has warned the process could still take years.
The Bottom Line
This is the biggest scandal English football has ever seen, and the final chapter is still unwritten. Will City face relegation, a multi-season deduction, or a successful appeal? Keep it locked to ShapHub Sport Blog for every twist. Drop your prediction in the comments: how many points should City lose?
You can also check out our YouTube for more sport news @ShapHub
